Brick, Ivy, and Brushstrokes: Why Mona Lisa Smile is My Autumn Movie
What's Behind the Smile? Revisiting Mona Lisa Smile
I love Mona Lisa Smile. I'll say it right at the start. Every autumn, when the light turns golden and the evenings get long, it's the first movie I reach for. Brick archways, wool skirts, leaves on the quad, and a professor with a satchel full of ideas: it feels like fall from the very first frame. It's also, to me, one of the most wonderful movies ever made about how to look at art.
The Setup
It's 1953, and Katherine Watson (Julia Roberts) has just arrived at Wellesley College to teach art history. She's a free-thinking Californian stepping into one of the most polished, tradition-bound women's colleges in America. The unofficial curriculum there is how to be a good wife: how to host, how to pour tea, how to smile on cue. Bright young women are groomed for graduation and, ideally, an engagement ring by the time they walk across the stage.
Watson's first class goes sideways in the best way. She launches into her lecture, only to find the students are ahead of her. They've already read the whole textbook and can recite every date and attribution.
What they've never been asked is what they actually think.
Teaching Students to Look
This is the heart of the film, and it's why I adore it. Watson sets the syllabus aside and shows her class work that isn't in the book, including the boldly abstract painting that was shaking up the art world in the 1950s. The students are baffled, defensive and sometimes dismissive. Is this really art? Who decided?
Her answer is not to hand them a verdict. She asks them to look, to say what they see, and to defend it. Anyone who has stood in a gallery in front of something confusing knows how uncomfortable and how exciting that is.
It's the lesson I think every art lover eventually learns. Knowing the artist, the year and the movement is useful, but it's the beginning. The rest is standing in front of the work and being honest about your response. This film gets that so right, and it made art history feel alive to me, like a conversation instead of a list of names and dates.
The Smile
The title comes from Leonardo da Vinci's, Mona Lisa, 1503-1517, and the film uses her as a metaphor. Painted in the early 1500s and now hanging in the Louvre, she has the most talked-about expression in art history. Part of that is Leonardo's sfumato technique, the soft, smoky blending that leaves the corners of her mouth deliberately ambiguous. Look at her from one angle and she seems amused. Look again and she seems to be holding something back.
Is she happy? Is she performing happiness? Is she simply a woman who knows something we don't?
That ambiguity is what the film is about. The young women of Wellesley are all wearing smiles, the ones they've been taught to wear, and Watson keeps gently asking what's underneath. I think that's such a beautiful way to use a painting: not as a trophy on a wall, but as a question you can hold up to your own life.
The Women Behind the Smiles
The students are what turn the film from a lecture on art into a story about people, and I love every one of them.
Betty (Kirsten Dunst) is polished, confident and fiercely loyal to the world she's been raised in. She's Watson's sharpest critic, and she carries some of the film's most affecting moments.
Joan (Julia Stiles) is brilliant and torn between the law school future she's earned and the marriage everyone expects. Her story is the one that speaks most directly to Watson's message about choice.
Giselle (Maggie Gyllenhaal) is witty, unapologetic and frank about wanting a life on her own terms. The class rebel, and a total joy to watch.
Connie (Ginnifer Goodwin) is thoughtful and self-conscious, quietly wondering whether she'll ever be chosen. Her arc is small and tender, and it's the one that stays with me longest.
Each of them is a portrait in the truest sense: a face that says one thing while the person behind it feels another.
The Look of It
Even setting the art history aside, this film is a feast for the eyes. Everything is warm and burnished: amber light, ivy-covered brick, tweed and cashmere, gloves and pearls. It's a fall palette in the fullest sense, and it makes the film a perfect seasonal rewatch. If you love a movie with atmosphere, this is the cinematic equivalent of your favorite sweater.
Why I Love It
Mona Lisa Smile wears its heart on its sleeve, and that's its greatest strength. It's earnest and emotional, and it says plainly what it believes: that women deserve real choices, and that art can help us find our own point of view. Not every film has the courage to be that sincere. It means every word, and I love it for that.
Three Things It Taught Me About Art
- Looking is an act of courage. Having an opinion about a painting means risking being challenged, and that risk is where the best conversations start.
- Context matters, but it isn't the whole story. Dates and movements give you a map. Your own response is the journey.
- Art can change how you see your life. That might be the real reason we keep going back to museums.
How to Watch It
Cardigan on. Something warm in a mug. Rain on the window if you can arrange it. When Watson's classroom scenes come on, pause and ask yourself what she asks her students: not what am I supposed to think? but what do I see? Then look again at the smiles on screen and wonder what might be underneath.
Your Turn
Have you seen Mona Lisa Smile? Is it a fall favorite for you too? Tell me in the comments. I'd love to hear what you see in her smile.
Comments
Post a Comment